在線辦公

期刊檢索

您當前的位置:首頁 >> 期刊目錄

《元朝秘史》中兩則諺語與相關史料的可靠性問題

查看全文 下載全文

摘要:

本文討論的《元朝秘史》所記第一條諺語,見于該書第85節記鐵木真幼年在逃避泰赤兀人追殺時,鎖兒罕失剌兩子間一段以草木尚且蔽護遭鷹鶻追捕的雀鳥為喻,力主救鐵木真之敘事。此比喻亦見于波斯史家志費尼《世界征服者史》中,有關諸王闊端拒絕向脫列哥那監國皇后交出大臣鎮海與牙剌瓦赤的回復,以及元人閻復《句容郡王紀績碑》記載的欽察王族不同意將收留的篾兒乞殘部交給成吉思汗時所舉理由中。第二條有關憑借觀察少年眼神靈活程度,來判斷其未來成長的蒙古諺語,除在《秘史》中兩見外,亦見于畏兀兒名臣孟速思與漢人劉哈剌八都魯的家傳資料。本文通過對這兩條蒙古諺語的分析,證明《句容郡王紀績碑》所記欽察王族淪為成吉思汗家族牧奴的過程,志費尼所述闊端拒絕向脫列哥那皇后交出鎮海與牙剌瓦赤之事,與孟速思與劉哈剌八都魯家傳資料中保存的他們初見成吉思汗與忽必烈時的情節,均是相當可靠的歷史記錄。



作者: 劉迎勝
作者單位: 南京大學民族與邊疆研究中心/元史研究室
期刊: 民族研究
年.(期):頁碼 2015.(5):0-0
中圖分類號:
文章編號:
關鍵詞: 蒙古諺語〓《元朝秘史》〓《世界征服者史》〓欽察〓孟速思〓哈剌八都魯

歡迎閱讀《民族研究》!您是該文第1705位讀者!

 
01彩票 www.5091a.com | www.low8937.com | www.371z.cc | 93936x.com | www.968tk.com | www.973320.com | 45637m.com | www.3333yh.vip | www.55885a.com | 4812222.com | www.89777f.com | kb080.com | www.1880204.com | www.655802.com | 3522mm.com | www.pj55717.com | 3126578.com | www.kj803.com | www.661526.com | 2846n.com | www.6699nsb.com | vn6588.com | www.3709885.com | www.742255.com | 3178ll.com | www.cc444.com | www.fyyy3.com | www.fc78.com | www.ks1384.com | wb8.com | www.gt111777.com | 62222o.com | www.qilc9.com | www.kelake66.com | 9p123.com | www.sx1855.com | www.mg4355888.com | 18775g.com | www.4058ll.com | 2677www.com | www.345512.com | www.z948z.com | 32126v.net | www.763226.com | www.kj306.com | k00333.com | www.800986.com | www.wns3558.com | 93922w.com | www.coz5.com | www.848883.com | 67890aa.com | www.am7654.com | www.kj33.com | 1708222.com | www.799417.com | www.mk856.com | 167605.com | www.914979.com | www.212323.com | 1294y.cc | www.599546.com | www.2019.com | 9030x.com | 99589cc.net | www.5551883.com | www.645suncity.com | 11422x.com | www.79520c.com | www.566455.com | 3534a.com | www.096610.com | www.sha2233.com | lewen123.com | 3730.com | www.ck7686.com | www.206037.com | 0080.com | 8128522.com | www.8667k.com | www.o9478.com | vns5.vip | 76886a.com | www.6628229.com | www.980143.com | 3640ss.com | www.426060.com | www.469700.com | www.8494v.com | 3522e.cc | www.557894.com | www.7893w36.com | 63963333.com | 28288mm.com | www.ct8844.com | www.h92776.com | 54443y.com | hjdc853.com | www.zfcp3.com | www.629820.com | zz3189.com | 1099528.com | www.qucp3.com | www.40288i.com | www.67797l.com | 38365e.com | www.106135.com | www.7240n.com | www.88051.com | 6665009.com | 3344blg.com | www.21czj.com | www.4996ts.com | www.benz4422s.com | j444000.com | www.155792.com | www.8d858.com | www.234894.com | 20779966.com | 3640w.com | 5446rr.com | www.ct8866.com | www.9895s.com | www.33569900.com | 983888x.com | 5804e.com | www.381860.com | www.39096.com | www.69589a.com | 33115tt.com | xpj44444.vip | www.452816.com | www.48283333.com | www.6696877.com | www.vn99.vn | 3614.com | 6667009.com | www.773593.com | www.967004.com | www.67msxfpt3.com | www.3459q.com | t222c.com | toucai55.com | www.29277u.com | www.33112n.com | www.46630.info | www.866666c.com | 6220c.com | 82365u.com | 11018a.com | www.396990.com | www.61268888.com | www.b12189.com | www.815333.com | www.555xin2.com | 6363xx.com | hkmh88.com | www.65707o.com | www.2109b.com | www.12136a.com | www.8828fh.com | www.32666x.com | 500000937.com | hg11330.com | 900089v.com | www.112070.com | www.c229.net | www.3978f.com | www.792051.com | www.48282222.com | www.1818xpj.com | n1429.com | hg886.com | pj8114.com | dfs234.com | www.296676.com | www.rrle7.com | www.89894n.com | www.4521q.com | www.qmc0055.com | www.774167.com | www.y1155.com | 2934w.com | ylg123456.net | 11.sb | 11989b.com | 5651u.com | www.187517.com | www.938905.com | www.66509.cc | www.hg56977.com | www.12136r.com | www.99113c.com | www.hy985.com | www.2078a.com | www.8124r.com | www.777xin2.com | 6220j.com | 2jsqqq.com | yy3336.com | 8569811e.com | spj09.net | 673305.com | 80850g.com | 1463.com | 38989i.com | feicai0724.com | www.41518t.com | www.379477.com | www.c6386.com | www.50064b.com | www.ampj3435.com | www.hg77760.com | www.7920m.com | www.79095d.com | www.4058uu.com | www.88.net | www.65066zz.com | www.5146z1.com | www.938968.com | www.mk939.com | www.jb8899.com | www.456099.com | www.803303.com | www.092365.com | www.76577a.com | www.vip6233.com | www.jinsha8.net | www.990998.com | www.70850.com | www.60245.com | www.60486b.com | www.456115.com | www.28249.com | www.67885.com | www.88jt99.com | www.55526b.com | www.jz3888.com | www.bwinyz21.com | www.xpj53516.com | www.6939b.com | www.90wb.top | www.32123q.com | www.33015.cc | www.965666.com | www.707602.com | www.220716.com | zbouyang.cn | 386kzb.com | 8822vn77.com | 6664661.com | pj88002.com | 66671k.com | xpj65.com | spj81.net | www.wn2068.com | www.87680t.com | www.vns4668.cc | www.7302004.com | www.51705.com | www.2021z.com | www.37377v.com | www.50054b.com | www.hm5222.com | www.555958.com | www.50989e.com | 2013055.com | 27878ee.com | 01234lll.com | 3434jjj.com | www.hg688bb.com | www.135suncity.com | www.938968.com | www.063801i.com | www.4833058.com | www.6832u.com | www.630565.com | 111000rr.com | 068089.com | 1588666.com | www.hg0233.com | www.k66111.com | www.374317.com | www.p2894.com | www.16878i.com | www.901572.com | hhh5144.com | 1168y.com | 49964.com | 6002o.com | www.20161122.com | www.19yh4.com | www.hg9388.com | www.4444y.cc | www.50024v.com | 7893w07.com | 7062004.com | xpj000555.com | www.mic999.com | www.673888h.com | www.aa155.com | www.706126.com | 30006s.com | 4488ccc.com | lt101.net | www.hg7644.com | www.4521j.com | www.32123z.com | www.202803.com | 15856h.com | 67877f.com | www.9679700.com | www.hg98091.com | www.13633.com | www.499428.com | 1389z.com | v8738.com | www.21365ww.com | www.n3065.com | www.7239a.com | www.286967.com | 44005002.com | 2934x.com | www.bet365605.com | www.527576.com | www.2418v.com | www.371931.com | jr9933.com | 87665n.com | www.hg514.com | www.4809e.com | www.705059.com | 1224.cc | zhcp30.com | www.656888.com | www.11599068.com | www.338032.com | 53262e.com | 88903838.com | www.99113y.com | www.9478g.com | 2018bet33.com | df8x.com | www.tk828.com | www.89777y.com | www.126438.com | 8159ee.cc | www.4938q.com | www.8080999i.com | www.739908.com | 316f.cc | www.9599677.net | www.yf230.com | www.077wy.com | 8159ddd.cc | zhcp05.com | www.57289.com | www.0270u.com | P35dd.com | 55797f.com | www.77852.com | www.0055wd.com | 149301.com | ddcp7.com | www.82409.com | www.35155k.com | 8003xl.com | 9964u.com | www.4078c.com | www.821619.com | 9566560.com | www.00618k.com | www.xpj13666.com | yongfengfa.com | 6150m.com | www.67886788.com | www.371n.cc | 737pcsi.cn | www.283804.com | www.0088hgaa.com | tz22777.com | 2805y.com | www.19019l.com | www.848966.com | 0615009.com | www.hg3455.com | www.77803l.com | 08778a.com | www.v32126.cc | www.4809x.com | 89892uu.com | 2418y.com | www.06386677.com | o8381.com | vns8z.com | www.1754o.com | www.60123u.com | 2190p.com | www.9b002.com | www.422323.com | 4036d.com | www.3846s.com | www.775702.com | 35222cc.com | www.0709.com | www.797884.com | 4288oo.com | www.js600000.com | www.610330.com | t72227.com | www.9737ww.com | www.192880.com | c51fal8.com | www.s063801.com | 92266m.com | www.jh839.com | www.hg118.com | 3616b.com | www.jsp02.com | www.ya022.com | 7599cc.com | www.jz95533.com | www.54400u.com | 1597442.com | www.amjs339.com | 61328866.com | www.yh8464.com | www.8499i.com | 55323u.com | www.4853.com | 22296ab.com | www.jsw66.cc | www.0270l.com | bowang22.com | www.5966aaa.com | www.339189.com | 8290f.com | www.883399e.com | js58881.com | www.2767t.com | www.876879.com | bali3377.com | www.55676r.com | 1591hhh.com | www.73kh.com | www.309825.com | p888.com | www.80075c.com | 3846yyy.com | www.5446hh.com | 77p1.cc | www.pj8793.com | www.984688.com | dazhuangjia.me | www.amjs119.com | cpyz6666.com | www.97060d.com | 8790z.com | www.hg0998.com | www.721560.com | 339449.net | www.60108w.com | mg887788.com | www.836bbb.com | xxx5144.com | www.255817.com | 59889r.com | www.03499.com | zyxxd.com | www.698012.com | www.517844.com | www.555xhtd.com | www.fcff0.com | 44qq8331.com | www.71399d.com | bet37544.com | www.6889782.com | qq8159.cc | www.83066.com | 6396x.com | www.3hg6668.com | 2381aaa.com | www.296977.com | 1168n.com | www.0752drf.com | 0088wd.com | www.643sunbet.com | 66569.com | www.789270.com | 22296ab.com | www.hqr77.com | 15856o.com | www.hg9688.com | 2381j.com | www.987111.com | 7888099.com | www.mm7777.com | 69234.cc | www.20199ee.com | 2222k11.com | www.68277.com | 1654q.com | www.848777i.com | 9149x.com | www.4521s.com | 4025l.com | www.55717j.com | 4182b.com | www.39957b.com | 55vn77.com | www.lycp886.com | www.76060t.com | www.507477.com | www.530405.com | www.33112u.com | www.66632.com | js75.com | www.4058u.com | shen3377.com | www.9646g.com | 8827kkk.com | www.clh9.com | www.10899d.com | www.095335.com | www.025sunbet.com | 36502w.com | www.3066tt.com | 3522ll.cc | www.4323v.com | 73657m.com | www.513477.com | www.9816666.com | 1479l.com | www.47506q.com | 1407.com | www.24czj.com | www.67797f.com | v0099.tv | www.673888y.com | fxc008.com | www.84577.com | www.76060g.com | www.33588v.com | www.c44ee.com | 1443b.com | www.yh7771.com | 589669.com | www.444739.com | www.0561drf.com | 3121g.com | www.ya2019t.com | www.glc33.com | www.50051o.com | www.170676.com | 4255uuu.com | www.99714.cc | www.txck.cc | 22296ww.com | www.8008553.com | 4997f.com | www.514918.com | www.190bo.com | dzc111.com | www.98599.cc | www.330099c.com | js26732.com:9885 | www.0343m.com | 58588b.com | 1314.xw252.com | www.bwinyz01.com | am8888.net | www.545680.com | www.hjcp2.com | hhgz0077.com | www.984688.com | www.300699.com | 463e8.com | www.3933j.cc | www.www242428.com | 9149g.com | www.00840z.com | www.pj5757.com | kbj7268.com | www.34788s.com | www.hg0462.com | 8884136.com | www.50051b.com | www.0151u.com | 1624ff.com | www.29277w.com | www.44889u.com | 444000.com | www.371n.cc | www.c15595.com | 3846xxx.com | www.609553.com | www.58665a.com | 4809u.com | www.010986.com | www.7225u.com | 7792s.com | 3222.com | www.hg118444.com | www.1504.com | 33013.com | www.6769a1.com | www.2945l.com | 112a.net | j1759.com | www.www014678.com | www.mgm007.com | 67890m.com | www.ybao0.com | www.5049p.com | 2306c.com | 2535b.com | www.6482b.com | www.22244066.com | 3967.com | www.290727.com | www.738055.com | www.8124x.com | lehu558.com | www.cb2988.com | www.cszb.com | c388s.com | 86811nn.com | www.5441n.com | www.3846u.com | 2846h.com | aipin888.net | www.2788cai.com | www.dzcp7777.com | P35v.com | 59599o.com | www.939884.com | www.686102a.com | www.ra6060.com | 242844.com | www.663738.com | www.369403.com | www.i22365.com | 4288x.com | www.202901.com | www.778305.com | www.z47.cc | 98955k.com | mgm3242g.com | www.29277y.com | www.58509.com | www.86611d.com | 8569811g.com | www.545669.com | www.pj55716.com | www.vns365x.net | 3685j.com | 99567z.com | www.1666ac.com | www.10999w.com | www.8694n.com | 4156.com | ca5055.com | www.2588cai.com | www.829797f.com | www.hg8086.com | 01234ll.com | 683bet.com | www.2875t.com | www.sha2299.com | www.29886j.com | 7742m.com | 38238d.com | www.788572.com | www.087u.com | www.6882f.com | 73567tg12.com | 054598.cc | 64111g.com | www.5086q.com | www.14k0048.com | www.32666j.com | 69441166.com | 6611412.com | www.80767u.com | www.33997g.com | www.9951331.com | www.9380l.com | 009900s.com | 0652g.com | 2306f.com | www.csgc1.com | www.56011g.com | www.591111.com | www.ks081.com | 4340y.com | 918dp.com | www.155233.com | www.9999y.cc | www.877636.com | www.hwx518.com | www.302981.com | 2jsggg.com | 883399s.com | 2490x.com | www.817055.com | www.w77929.com | www.26123ff.com | www.259681.com | www.jh879.com | 7742m.com | 867203.com | 5647s.com | www.608520.com | www.0270o.com | www.678js444.com | www.57289.com | www.55268uu.com | x86002.com | 3957p.com | 8722llll.com | 5144s.com | www.258768.com | www.8fk.com | www.566493.com | www.j3678.com | www.hv588.com | www.7111b.com | 73567tg12.com | y2537.com | 0805o.com | 44488c.com | 50000997.com | www.178591.com | www.c71.cc | www.71233k.com | www.d94600.com | www.55070r.com | www.990654.com | www.65471188.com | www.28758k.com | 3844ww.com | vns9539.com | gg40033.com | jjjj19927.com | daohang3801.com | 8381k.com | www.317990.com | www.925771.com | www.11018.cc | www.90920.com | www.pj55716.com | www.694916.com | www.615073.com | www.853789.com | www.9949k.com | www.365815n.com | www.cr4888.com | 99663885.com | 168cp-m.com | 2325.cc | 8977aa.com | q86226.com | 2324jjj.com | 3143.cc | 997799.net | 4812d.com | 6868qq.cc | 125588.com | 6hcc88.com | 33dd8332.com | 3568j.com | hunibe.com | 89777l.com | 69990g.com | 230466.com | 5006811.com | 19991t.com | 66300vip03.com | www.43131b.com | www.178612.com | www.271902.com | www.501203.com | www.586198.com | www.626990.com | www.643388.com | www.658770.com | www.599846.com | www.586031.com | www.588730.com | www.558423.com | www.466518.com | www.375769.com | www.314577.com | www.196016.com | www.205883.com | www.081503.com | 79964c.com | vv3396.com | 4997.com | 91599.com | 50067k.com | 30009.com | 123456yy.cc | cao618.com | 371056.com | 6261520.com | yz6388.com | 26444j.com | 61652k.com | www.7669a.net | www.77537x.com | www.a80065.com | www.4519.com | www.27363m.com | www.686102a.com | www.g2894.com | www.308105.com | www.70203d.cc | www.29277d.com | www.c6712.com | www.542676.com | www.97655u.com | nf6655.com | 6033i.com | 0698e.com | 4255hh.com | 11989o.com | www.cr448.com | www.88837z.com | www.jty449.com | www.557789.com | www.9895x.com | www.4988c.cc | www.3890d.com | www.866367.com | www.137101.com | z58955.com | 84497766.com | 36405511.com | D8.com | www.55268j.vip | www.9f33.com | www.4694i.com | www.3522 | www.21202x.com | www.686536.com | 38238a | 4052n.com | 4036e.com | 6641gg.com | www.330099v.com | www.hrtsh.com | www.417920.com | www.84499x.com | www.810872.com | 78118866.com | 10050718.com | 01885a.com | www.yh8007.com | www.hg2258.com | www.9737zz.com | www.35898e.com | www.an966.com | www.88065e.com | bcylc999.com | bb32355.com | 90307s.com | www.37533.com | www.xpj66696.com | www.5647q.com | www.903117.com | bbb7570.com | 3045522.com | 2820s.com | www.166242.com | www.4963ee.com | www.0194007.com | www.781367.com | 1105596.com | 8159v.cc | 78118844.com | www.hg7211z.com | www.f12189.com | www.36788y.com | www.210639.com | 206402.com | 6261v.com | www.9679a.com | www.932367.com | www.7714g.com | www.397836.com | 1253-6.com | 45637b.com | www.1zbvip.com | www.6880xx.com | www.66907.cc | 56987qq.com | 13852018.com | www.033033u.com | www.50025b.com | www.1434o.com | www.859509.com | 3644k.com | xx7742.com | www.307607.com | www.47506q.com | www.ya077.com | hutu87.com | 4809o.com | www.3643n.com | www.35700b.com | www.371l.cc | 2934g.com | 6261dd.com | www.blm5544.com | www.22ok22.com | www.775709.com | gg69096.com | 2247f.com | www.447858.com | www.108011.com | www.35155o.com | 36402244.com | www.v3308.com | www.7893w34.com | www.cz5658.com | 5802cc.com | 2019pp.cc | www.jjjj44444.com | www.16878o.com | 8547yy.com | 3552g.com | www.am1111.cc | www.4444msc.com | www.460689.com | 99698w.com | www.hg226.com | www.466890.com | www.855312.com | 3559zz.com | www.55564400.com | www.p3065.com | www.27czj.com | 69096h.com | 59599z.com | www.5099yy.com | www.927320.com | 7920com.com | www.wns911.com | www.6687l.com | www.506729.com | hc333.vip | www.3046w.com | www.fg9907.com | 033e.net | 01885l.com | www.333wh.com | www.26878q.com | 2381nn.com | www.y1311.com | www.932418.com | www.378016.com | pp3405.com | www.777888yh.com | www.52072z.com | feicai0892.com | www.00396.com | www.115527b.com | www.327477.com | 22296zt.com | www.569389.com | www.33112r.com | 386kzk.com | www.9374g.com | www.980879.com | c388z.com | 50000022.com | www.8313e.com | www.577032.com | 13222s.com | www.233113.com | www.8mcp.com | 00773k.com | www.hg58.pw | www.68682g.com | yd12308.com | www.26777.cc | www.947004.com | hg4668.com | www.333222o.com | www.hr1855.com | 416164.com | www.bm10000.com | www.44118r.com | js75aa.com | 668866.com | www.wns123g.com | 9645ee.com | 1408f.com | www.778305.com | 0033p.cc | www.yinhecc99.com | www.fg9907.com | t1429.com | www.x30226.com | www.83033k.com | 5651k.com | www.888zr61.com | www.371m.cc | 3435q.com | www.hf9012.com | www.450568.com | 538.cc | www.99552ff.com | hg999333p.com | www.7435f.com | www.16065l.com | 2077bb.com | www.155439.com | www.75wcp.com | 7052004.com | www.58665g.com | www.187380.com | 776059.com | www.q63568.com | 0234f.com | www.16297711.com | www.22qxc.com | 8159uuu.cc | www.377838.com | spsgz.com | www.hg3388.org | www.20899.com | 33599ff.com | www.118vv.com | www.330295.com | 68963000.com | www.441394.com | 5369t.com | www.644234.com | www.577032.com | 2677zzz.com | www.25683.com | 4036cc.com | www.13383.com | www.244689.com | hg999333c.com | www.0601f.com | 83378a.com | www.lm55.com | 524350.com | www.00829h.com | www.11tdc.com | 22ww8332.com | www.81508z.com | 5369b.com | www.444230.com | www.221085.com | www.wn2038.com | www.39500s.com | 4107j.com | www.45598j.com | 139702.com | www.xg78.com | www.068617.com | www.25673e.com | www.gai20.com | 88807e.com | www.13434e.com | 4775511.com | www.bwinyz48.com | 3656pp.com | www.vnsr188.com | www.073818.com | www.76543q.com | www.976917.com | 6868ll.cc | www.08588h.com | ahga008.com | www.63683.com |